One of the most ridiculous phrases that's repeated over and over in America is "we need to protect our children."For the record, I'm all for protecting children from child molesters, violent crime, emotional and physical abuse, fires, sharp toys and drinking cleaning products, but more often than not, we're spinning our wheels trying to "protect" children from things that aren't dangerous. Like pop music.
I was listening the song Run This Town on the radio last night, when I heard the word dick replaced with silence. It isn't news, of course, that the FCC refuses to let the more colorful bits of our language be used on radio and TV, but having Kanye make reference to getting a lot of attention ("...everybody on yo' dick...") is hardly something that children need to be protected from.
What's the fear, anyway? That a child might use the word dick? I don't mean to burst anyone's bubble, but my friends and I used the word in third grade. The assumption that having a 10-year old say, "He's a dick" will somehow corrupt her innocence is ridiculous and plays into the naïve fantasy that children need to be insulated from the world, anyway.
Do you have friends? Go online? Go out in public? Swearing isn't some activity reserved for prostitutes and drug dealers, it's part of our culture. Get over it.
And what of this desire to protect our children from the cruel world that "they'll discover soon enough?" News flash: we don't live in 1992-era Bosnia. Our children aren't about to enter a world of gun fire and genocide. It is not imperative that we let them live in a fairytale for 18 years because the harsh reality of the world is going to crush them. They're going to grow up and be adults in an advanced and developed nation with the largest economy and one of the highest standards of living on the planet.
Oh, protect them from the rest of the world, maybe? Pretend that there aren't regions of the globe where people are tortured, kidnapped, murdered? So that America's children can grow into adults who don't understand what life is like outside their own suburbs? So that we can continue to propagate the cultural maxim "out of sight, out of mind"?
Bleeping out Kanye West lyrics doesn't cause this cultural ignorance, of course, but it's an example of what America does to keep its people living in a more-perfect, albeit highly altered reality that permits our cheery optimism. And we start it at birth.
I'd like to see America use the word "shit" on TV, so we're not ashamed to be crude. I'd like to see us talk candidly about sex, so we can address the problems related to it. I'd like to see boobs on TV so that as a culture, we can stop exoticizing and eroticizing everything about women's bodies.
We're so entrenched in feeling dirty about swearing, feeling embarrassed talking about something that 99% of us do and looking at breasts that we've enacted agencies to make sure that people don't do it in public.
"We do it to protect the kids," we say.
But it's all bullshit. We do it to reinforce the American fantasy that life is beautiful and rosy because we're afraid of letting reality permeate our perfect world. But this tendency to live in a perfectly concocted fantasy instead of an imperfect reality makes problems for us. It keeps us reaching for shit-ain't-there: the perfect job, the perfect house, the perfect mate. It prevents us from reading the real news; we have to read about reality stars with eight kids and former vice-presidential candidates' family drama. We just can't bear the prospect of reading about human rights abuses in Sub-Saharan Africa.
One could argue that American optimism is tied to this belief that things can be perfect and that that optimism has helped us immensely as a culture. And it probably has. We've pushed ahead, developed solutions for problems and developed a dynamic culture that has been exported to every nook and cranny of the planet.
But things are really perfect only in fairy tales. And we only tell these to children. So can we agree that, as a culture, the fairy tale is over? Can we grow up now? Can we stop this cultural game of "girls have cooties, keep your shirt on"? Or of "you said a bad word, I'm telling teacher on you"?
The sooner we stop using "protecting our children" as a euphemism for "preserving our fantasy," the sooner we can grow as a culture.
We've convinced ourselves that childhood fantasies are where it's at. "Be a kid at heart," we say.
Why? Growing up isn't a bad thing; how about being an adult at heart? Why do we resist growing up?
As adults, we have more responsibilities than we did as kids. But we also have more freedom. It can be nice to go home for a weekend and let Mom and Dad cook and clean for you, but would you ever really want to be a child again? Have a curfew? Let the comforts of childhood strip you of the liberation of adulthood? I certainly wouldn't.
And I don't think we should force our culture to live in infancy forever, either. We have a brilliant, educated and diverse culture, let's let it grow up.



